The Question Psychiatry Cannot Answer: If Depression Is a Chemical Imbalance, What Threw It Off?

Psychiatry long claimed there’s a “chemical imbalance,” in mental illness, but it never answers the obvious questions: if it’s chemical, what threw it off? Why now? Why not at birth? And why does it so often follow trauma, neglect, chronic stress, or loss?

Looking at the facts, the assertion falls apart. The “chemical imbalance” idea was simply an effective marketing slogan, not science. It gave doctors something to say, patients something to believe, and pharmaceutical companies something to sell. But it ignores what Interpersonal Neurobiology shows clearly: that our emotional states emerge from our lived experiences, our relationships, and the safety or danger our nervous system perceives over time.

When someone’s life becomes too unsafe, too demanding, too isolating, the system adapts. The so-called “depression” is not a broken brain, but the body’s way of reducing output to survive unrelenting overwhelm. It’s a survival adaptation to chronic threat or depletion.

So what disturbed the balance? The same thing that disturbs any living system: too much demand, too little support, too much fear, or not enough care. When life becomes something to endure instead of something that feels safe to inhabit, the body protects itself the only way it can. And psychiatry, instead of asking why, numbs the messenger and calls it treatment.

But it makes sense when we understand that 💊💊🟰💲💲‼️

 

 

 

About Shay Seaborne, CPTSD

Shay Seaborne CPTSD teaches Relational Neuroscience for stress reduction, trauma recovery, and community building. Shay has studied the neurobiology of fear / trauma /PTSD since 2014 and Interpersonal Neurobiology (IPNB) since 2019. They write, speak, teach, and make art to convey their experiences as well as their understanding of the neurobiology of fear, trauma theory, Interpersonal Neurobiology concepts, and principles of trauma recovery. A native of Northern Virginia, Shay settled in Delaware to sail KALMAR NYCKEL, the state’s tall ship. But once they finally had mental health insurance, their life rapidly changed. The standard treatment for PTSD nearly killed them. The psychiatric abuse began a cascade of negative medical encounters that repeatedly caused additional harm and the development of severe Medical PTSD. Shay wishes everyone could recognize that "mental health problems" are symptoms of dysregulation, our mainstream culture is neuro-negative, and we can heal ourselves and each other through awareness, understanding, and safe connection.
This entry was posted in Psychiatry. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to The Question Psychiatry Cannot Answer: If Depression Is a Chemical Imbalance, What Threw It Off?

  1. Nancy says:

    I instantly related to your article. Makes perfect sense to me!!! Thank you! ❤️

Leave a Reply